--- title: "FMCG Complexity: Factory Efficiency versus Operating Company Cost" description: Where should you locate necessary FMCG sku complexity? image: https://supplychain.enchange.com/hs-fs/file-15792508-jpg/blog_images/skus3-resized-600.jpg --- [Login](https://www.enchange.com/login/) - - - - [![Enchange](https://supplychain.enchange.com/hubfs/Enchange_October2019/Image/logo.png)](https://www.enchange.com/) # Route to Market & Supply Chain Blog # FMCG Complexity: Factory Efficiency versus Operating Company Cost Posted by Dave Jordan on Thu, Mar 03, 2011 - [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share) Initiatives such as 6-Sigma and TPM have helped producers towards optimised output from their manufacturing networks. Line changeovers are carried out with Grand Prix slickness. Packaging components have been harmonised and rationalised. Output reliability and product quality have never been better. But how much of that output actually ends up in retailer warehouses in exactly the same condition? Potentially, very little! The [product leaving the factory](https://supplychain.enchange.com/bid/31429/The-Top-10-Smash-Hits-of-FMCG-Route-to-Market-Distribution) is frequently changed in some way before a consumer picks it off the shelf. The power of retailers means one will want a 6-pack while others opt for 4-packs. Promotional assembly requires the pristine external packaging to be removed (and discarded?) while skus are bundled together or stickered with “special price” labels. All of this requires time and considerable cost. So where should the complexity sit; factory or in the local operating company warehouse? FMCG producers in particular have slowly but surely reduced the number of under utilised factories in order to make assets sweat in large, regional facilities. Adding a discrete language label for a low volume product destined for a small developing market would upset the KPI chart so it does not happen, perhaps rightly. However this then puts the burden of market development on fledging operating companies. If the product is made by a 3rd party then perhaps this is the correct approach but usually the factory and operating company are part of the same multi-national. Yes, the two entities may well have separate legal and tax set-ups but at the end of the day all the profit (or loss) goes into one pot. ![sku complexity reduction](https://supplychain.enchange.com/hs-fs/file-15792508-jpg/blog_images/skus3-resized-600.jpg)Blue-chip companies and their shareholders increasingly rely on [developing and emerging (D&E) markets](https://supplychain.enchange.com/bid/32173/The-Challenges-of-FMCG-Supply-Chain-Route-to-Market-in-West-Africa) for growth as mature markets struggle along with low single digit or negative growth. The common rejection of a request for product X for small country Y is that the volume is not high enough to warrant a dedicated sku or even a place on the back label language cluster. If you place the re-pack/co-pack financial and slow-to-react burden on their shoulders then the likelihood is that their volumes will always be small as they fail to gain manufacturing efficiency benefits. I do not suggest for example that companies should produce a special pack for a place such as the Isle of Man but there is the dilemma. Do you back slick factories and let the operating companies deal with complexity or vice versa? Tags: [SKU](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/sku), [FMCG](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/fmcg), [Dave Jordan](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/dave-jordan), [Performance Improvement](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/performance-improvement), [Manufacturing Footprint](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/manufacturing-footprint) ### Subscribe Here! ## Implementation Guide - 20 Steps to RtM Excellence [![cta-20-steps-implementation-guide-1](https://supplychain.enchange.com/hs-fs/hubfs/cta-20-steps-implementation-guide-1.png?width=336&name=cta-20-steps-implementation-guide-1.png)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/implementation-guide-to-20-steps-to-route-to-market-excellence) ## RtM Distributor Assessment Tool [![rtm-distributin-assessment-tool-enchange](https://supplychain.enchange.com/hs-fs/hubfs/rtm-distributin-assessment-tool-enchange.png?width=336&name=rtm-distributin-assessment-tool-enchange.png)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/analyse-the-performance-of-your-distributors---free-route-to-market-assessment-form) ## Distributor Assessment Guide [![distributor assessment guide-2](https://supplychain.enchange.com/hubfs/Enchange_October2019/Image/distributor%20assessment%20guide-2.webp)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/distributor-assessment-guide) ## 3rd Degree Partnership Guide [![3rd degree partnership download](https://supplychain.enchange.com/hubfs/Enchange_October2019/Image/3rd%20degree%20partnership%20download.webp)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/implementing-third-degree-partnerships-guide) ## Indirect Distribution: FMCG  Distributors vs. Wholesalers [![cta_ditributor-wholesale-download_sidebar](https://supplychain.enchange.com/hs-fs/hubfs/cta_ditributor-wholesale-download_sidebar.png?width=336&name=cta_ditributor-wholesale-download_sidebar.png)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/indirect-distribution-fmcg-distributors-vs.-wholesalers) ## 8 Steps to Drive Distributor Excellence ![cta-8-steps-distributor-excellence](https://supplychain.enchange.com/hs-fs/hubfs/cta-8-steps-distributor-excellence.png?width=336&name=cta-8-steps-distributor-excellence.png)   [![awrad](https://supplychain.enchange.com/hubfs/Enchange_October2019/Image/Supply-Chain-transparent_216px.png)](http://blog.feedspot.com/supply_chain_blogs/) ### Connect with Enchange Online ### Posts by Topics - [Dave Jordan (432)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/dave-jordan) - [FMCG (386)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/fmcg) - [Supply Chain (249)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/supply-chain) - [S&OP (226)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/sop) - [Route to Market (202)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/route-to-market) - [Forecasting & Demand Planning (177)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/forecasting-demand-planning) - [Performance Improvement (175)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/performance-improvement) - [Distribution (141)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/distribution) - [Traditional Trade (114)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/traditional-trade) - [Sales (112)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/sales) - [CEO (111)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/ceo) - [Inventory Management & Stock Control (105)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/inventory-management-stock-control) - [Humour (94)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/humour) - [Brewing & Beverages (88)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/brewing-beverages) - [Michael Thompson (88)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/michael-thompson) - [Pharma (84)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/pharma) - [RTM Assessment Tool (83)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/rtm-assessment-tool) - [RTM (77)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/rtm) - [RtM Strategy (74)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/rtm-strategy) - [Logistics Management (71)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/logistics-management) - [CEE (67)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/cee) - [Ross Marie (64)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/ross-marie) - [20 Steps to RtM Excellence (63)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/20-steps-to-rtm-excellence) - [Customer service (63)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/customer-service) - [KPI (61)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/kpi) - [SKU (57)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/sku) - [Logistics Service Provider (48)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/logistics-service-provider) - [Cost Reduction (37)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/cost-reduction) - [Retail (37)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/retail) - [Supply Chain House (36)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/supply-chain-house) - [supply chain excellence (35)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/supply-chain-excellence) - [Doing Business in Africa (31)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/doing-business-in-africa) - [ERP/SAP (30)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/erp-sap) - [Supply Chain Analytics (30)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/supply-chain-analytics) - [Christmas (28)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/christmas) - [Integrated Business Planning (28)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/integrated-business-planning) - [The ABC of RtM (27)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/the-abc-of-rtm) - [Interim Management (22)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/interim-management) - [Promotions (22)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/promotions) - [Manufacturing Footprint (18)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/manufacturing-footprint) - [IT (12)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/it) - [3PL (10)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/3pl) - [Information (10)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/information) - [Order to Cash (10)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/order-to-cash) - [Logistica Management (9)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/logistica-management) - [Mergers & Acquisitions (9)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/mergers-acquisitions) - [Telecoms (9)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/telecoms) - [4PL (6)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/4pl) - [Compliance (6)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/compliance) - [ERP (6)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/erp) - [Transportation (6)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/transportation) - [3PLP (5)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/3plp) - [Communication (5)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/communication) - [Sourcing (5)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/sourcing) - [Keith Marshall (4)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/keith-marshall) - [Outsourcing (4)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/outsourcing) - [Spare Parts (4)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/spare-parts) - [Stefan Cucu (4)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/stefan-cucu) - [Vietnam (4)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/vietnam) - [covid19 (4)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/covid19) - [Balanced Scorecard (3)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/balanced-scorecard) - [DIY (3)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/diy) - [DRS (3)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/drs) - [Digital (3)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/digital) - [Production Planning (3)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/production-planning) - [Ratib Ratib (3)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/ratib-ratib) - [Recovery (3)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/recovery) - [SUPPLY PLANNING (3)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/supply-planning) - [Andy Dixon (2)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/andy-dixon) - [IBP (2)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/ibp) - [Low Carbon (2)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/low-carbon) - [Planning (2)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/planning) - [Private Equity (2)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/private-equity) - [Supply Chain Strategy (2)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/supply-chain-strategy) - [WMS (2)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/wms) - [Warehousing (2)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/warehousing) - [Wholesale (2)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/wholesale) - [Agrochemicals (1)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/agrochemicals) - [Aristide Kouame (1)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/aristide-kouame) - [CONSULTING (1)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/consulting) - [Deposit Recovery Scheme (1)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/deposit-recovery-scheme) - [Dianna Vorpagel (1)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/dianna-vorpagel) - [Dumisani Siziba (1)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/dumisani-siziba) - [Food (1)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/food) - [HR (1)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/hr) - [INNOVATION (1)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/innovation) - [Make (1)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/make) - [Manufacturing (1)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/manufacturing) - [Refillable PET (1)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/refillable-pet) - [Scheduling (1)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/scheduling) - [WASTE (1)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/waste) - [finance (1)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/finance) - [procurement (1)](https://supplychain.enchange.com/topic/procurement) [See all](https://supplychain.enchange.com/bid/36518/FMCG-Complexity-Factory-Efficiency-versus-Operating-Company-Cost#) Enchange Registered office: 2 Piries Place, Horsham, West Sussex, RH12 1EH, UK.   Enchange Limited is a company registered in England and Wales with company number 2862912.  Enchange VAT number: 528 7834 08                                                                                   ©2019 Enchange Ltd. All rights reserved [Privacy Policy](https://www.enchange.com/privacy-policy) [Cookies](https://www.enchange.com/cookie-policy/)